In brief
The news of Chicago-born Leo XIV becoming the first American pope has prompted mixed reactions of pride, surprise, and curiosity among citizens.
May 8, 2025, marked a momentous occasion as Chicago Cardinal Leo XIV was elected as the first American pope, an event that reverberated across the nation. The announcement sparked feelings of patriotic pride among many, who saw it as a significant milestone for a 2,000-year-old institution choosing a leader from the United States, coinciding with the country's upcoming 250th anniversary. “To have the first American pope is something new and something fresh,” remarked Alex Freeman, a 33-year-old Atlanta event planner who occasionally participates in Catholic services. In the Windy City, the mood was celebratory, particularly among those who had personal connections to the new pontiff. Rev. William Lego, a former classmate of the pope, expressed disbelief and excitement, stating, “I think my classmate just got it.” The announcement elicited astonishment from various quarters, including political circles. David Axelrod, a prominent Democratic strategist, famously reacted with an exuberant “Holy smokes!!” on social media.However, the news also revealed a lack of familiarity among some Americans; for instance, Danielle Charles, an insurance professional in San Antonio, admitted she was unaware of the existence of a U.S. cardinal in the running. Similarly, Rosario Gonzales, a retired accountant in Queens, noted that her preference for the new pope was indifferent to nationality, asserting, “It doesn’t matter what nationality the pope is.” Despite knowing little about Leo XIV prior to the announcement, she added, “He looks the part,” expressing her hopes for his continuation of outreach efforts akin to Pope Francis.As the country processes this historic moment, many look forward to how an American pope might influence the church and society at large, continuing the traditions of compassion and dialogue established by his predecessor.
